Showing posts with label War in Iraq. Show all posts
Showing posts with label War in Iraq. Show all posts

Tuesday, April 8, 2008

A Marine Versus His Sister

I can sum up my opinions of the Iraq war simply by saying I am anti-war, anti-Bush, and I want our troops out of Iraq. I was against the war from the start and was completely against the troop surge. But, my story is much more complicated than the average, impersonal outlook on the war. My brother, Joseph Marzzacco is a United States Marine who served a year long tour of duty in Iraq. Most Americans are now against the war and against Bush, we know this. But, what do the troops who are actually fighting this war think of all these issues, and how will they vote in the upcoming election? By talking to my brother, I learned that for two people who grew up side by side, we have completely opposite opinions of these current events.

I will openly say I hated Bush from the beginning. When he sent my brother to Iraq I hated him even more. But, the person who had to deal with actually being there supports Bush. Why is this? As Joe explained, “I do support President Bush and have from the beginning. Everyone has forgotten about how he united this country after 9/11.”

The war in Iraq, in my opinion, was a mistake from the beginning, along with the troop surge. I always find it hard to believe when I hear people saying that they support it. According to my brother, “I supported the war from the beginning. That’s why I became a Marine. I will say that we could’ve waited to go into Iraq, but again, from what I know; another 9/11 could’ve been launched from Iraq if we didn’t act and I do believe the troop surge has been working. Casualties will go down and the Iraqi Army will have more time to train.”

In my opinion, our troops need to be pulled out of Iraq immediately. When I said this to my brother, he was really offended. He said, “I honestly don’t believe we will ever be completely out of Iraq. We will definitely have bases their similar to the ones in Japan, Germany, and South Korea. If we were to pull out completely, Iraq would be at risk of falling into the hands of another dictator and we’d have to go back in a few years anyway.

From what I’ve heard from the Democrats, troops deployed to Iraq were not getting the benefits they needed or benefits for their families. But, what my brother told me completely discredits the information I have. He explained, “I do feel that injured troops get good benefits. I have a combat related disability and the treatment and compensation I receive are much better than I would’ve gotten from a work related injury in the private sector. Also, the benefits have increased every year. When I was deployed, my wife gave birth to our son while caring for our daughter. She was eligible to leave work and receive benefits including my combat pay, military health insurance, and separation pay. How do you think she survived?”

The main thing I was eager to hear from my brother, were his opinions about the candidates in the upcoming Presidential election. From what I know about him, I probably could’ve guessed who he’d support. “I can’t answer for all troops, but I support Senator McCain. He has the military background to make good decisions regarding our security and safety. On the Democratic side, I like Obama. But, I could never support a candidate who wants to lead this country but has not served in the military himself.

Like I said, my brother and I have really conflicting opinions about war, the President, and the upcoming election. However, I will admit that what he told me really makes sense when looking at it from his perspective. He said it best when he told me, “Everyone is entitled to their opinions of the war and politics. But, it is one thing to debate it in a classroom full of people who don’t understand war and then to actually get your boots on the ground in Iraq and have the honor to fight for your country.” So many American families are being torn apart by their conflicting opinions about these issues. You should always say exactly what you feel, but when someone disagrees with us, we have to respect them. In my situation, taking my own advice is harder than it sounds and is a work in progress.

Katie Marzzacco ‘09
Communication Studies
Wilkes University

Monday, March 10, 2008

War in Iraq: My Number One Priority

Hey, remember that war? You know, the one with death tolls over 600,000? (washingtonpost.com) The War, which is very much still raging, has seemingly slipped from America’s list of pressing issues. Why is this? What it all comes down to is the fact that the war is being fought in another part of the world. Here in America, we are separated from the real ugliness of it. Also, the truth is that after 9/11 there was an outburst of patriotism. By now, it has sadly seemed to fade. People have replaced their thoughts of the war with the issues that are affecting them on a daily basis.

According to City-Data.com, the most important issue on Americans’ minds is the economy. The bad economy is a problem that is caused by many different factors. The outsourcing of jobs to foreign countries and the lack of jobs available to our college graduates are two examples of problems contributing to the current state of the economy. However, what many people fail to notice is that there is a very strong link between the issues with the economy and the War in Iraq. According to nationalpriorities.org the war is costing us $275 million per day!

For thousands of wives, children, parents, and siblings, the War is still very real and a horror that is impossible to rid from the mind. My brother, a United States Marine, spent a year in Iraq and it is impossible to describe the fear that was present in the minds of my family each and every day until he returned. I know it is impossible to really understand the relevance of this war unless you have some personal stake in it, but for the benefit of the troops still in Iraq and their families, we really need to. As Americans we need to band together and keep supporting our brothers and sisters who are literally risking their lives every day. They at least deserved to be kept in our thoughts, even if the media doesn’t remind us anymore.

Katie Marzzacco '09
Wilkes University
Communication Studies

Thursday, February 21, 2008

Help for Veterans of Iraqi War


I’m pretty sure if you’re the typical movie going American citizen, you have seen the award winning film, Forrest Gump. Lieutenant Dan, an unforgettable character, gets wounded from a battle deep within the jungles of Vietnam. Eventually it resulted in the loss of his legs. Over the course of the movie’s 142 minutes you saw the dramatic rise and fall of this character as he accepted and then refused a fate he didn’t deserve. What’s particularly sad is that Lt. Dan was a foreshadowing of a harsh reality facing returning troops from Iraq.

More and more, I hear stories of young adults around my age, 22, returning home from Iraq without limbs, with dependencies, suffering from PTS and the worst fate—death. We live in a country that claims to be #1, but we haven’t accepted responsibility for providing help to our modern day veterans.

In 2005, The Washington Post ran an article about a wounded veteran, Robert Loria, who returned from Iraq to find out that the government turned its back on him.

Loria had his hand blown off and could not walk as well. As pain increased significantly throughout his body the last thing that entered his mind was him owing money to the U.S. Army. He was hit with a $6,200 debt after putting his life on the line that would eventually alter his bodily functions forever. When The Washington Post looked into this situation, they found 331 soldiers also dealt with this problem. When military authority higher-ups were questioned, the only response they gave was a computer malfunction was messing up the debts (George, A01).

Along with financial problems and physical complications that arise from this war, some of the worse are long term psychological effects that remain untreated. Since the Vietnam conflict, Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD) has been a main concern and those who suffer from PTSD experience anxiety, depression, sleeplessness, flashbacks, wariness, and in extreme cases, suicide. One of these extreme cases is Marine Lance Cpl. James Jenkins.

Jenkins was a Marine who survived a fifty-five hour battle with the Mahdi militia in Najaf which would eventually mess him up. After returning home he couldn’t sleep for some time because of the hyper sensitive activity of the war and took up gambling which turned into a major problem and even bigger debts. Soon after Jenkins couldn’t function and would eventually take his life. The reason behind this terrible incident was the lack of medical assistance with PTSD (Dobie).

Everyday the news is awash with political jargon and pseudo promises of a better future for America. We’ve heard “change” and “hope” repeated like an old style vinyl record that’s been overplayed too many times. Yet one topic that hasn’t been touched upon enough in presidential debates is treatment of returning veterans. Why is it that these soldiers who are putting there lives on the line for a better world are being pushed aside?

Shouldn’t the current administration be concerned about offering assistance to men and women, to mothers and fathers, and most of all, to these kids? Maybe they should make sure that all returning veterans get the assistance they need whether it is mental, physical or financial.

Citations:
St. George, Donna. “For Injured U.S. Troops, ‘Financial Friendly Fire’.
Washington Post 14 Oct. 20005:A01.

Dobie, Kathy. “Denial in the Corps.” The Nation. 2008. Truthout Issues. 18 Feb. 2008

Matthew Gobbler '08
Wilkes University
Communications Studies

What’s Really Going On: A Marine’s Perspective on the Surge and Withdrawal of Troops in Iraq

We are experiencing a historical race for the White House in this year of 2008. One of the main issues in this campaign for me, my peers, my family, and my friends is the undeclared war in Iraq. Many of you may have heard Senator McCain and President Bush sing praises about the successful surge in Iraq, and the negatives associated with pulling our troops out.

Everyone is entitled to their opinion, but can we really know how things are going in Iraq if we are not there? To attempt to answer this question I wrote to a Marine who is a friend, Squad Leader LCPL Wehmeier M.E USMC/0311, and asked him if he thinks that the surge is working, and if he feels that troops should start being pulled out.
This is what Mike said:

“I think that the surged worked and we need to start pulling some forces out, however we need to better train the Iraqi police and army. Which they have a team called MITT which works with them. But, as an occupying force we need to start leaving.”

Mike believes the surge worked or is working, but the crucial point he made is that “-as an occupying force we need to start leaving”.

Squad Leader Wehmeier is an old friend of mine who, in my opinion, is currently serving in an undeclared, unjustified war. Along with many other friends and all of the other mothers, fathers, sisters, brothers, and family members who have a loved one in Iraq, I need to know this is a top priority in the 2008 campaign. This is my primary concern, the loss of innocent lives due to an undeclared war that should never have been started. It is 2008; we are civilized human beings that should be able to end conflicts without war.

My heart goes out to these men and women every day. Even if the surge did work, it’s time to end the violence.

The next man or woman to take over the Presidency will have to make this monumental decision as to whether or not to start pulling troops out and ending this “war.” All we can do is hope that they make the right decision.

Gina Bove '08
Wilkes University
Communication Studies

Monday, April 16, 2007

Bring our troops home.

Dear Mr. President,

It is time to bring the troops out of Iraq not time to send more in. Every American is asking, when will it end? After four years, you would think our troops would be home, safe and sound. Yet here you are advocating sending more troops into the chaos. January 10, 2007 you asked for 20,000 more troops be sent into Iraq; part of your New Way Forward Plan. Last week that number grew to 30,000. When will you realize that enough is enough? It is time to bring the troops out of Iraq not time to send more in. How many innocent lives must be lost before you realize that you made a huge mistake sending us into this war? A strong President would have the courage to admit that he made a mistake and take action to correct it. You, Mr. President, on the other hand hide behind “the war on terrorism”; trying to make Americans believe that the only way to succeed is to continue this ludicrous fight; a fight, a battle, a war that no longer has a convincing cause. It is time to realize that many Americans no longer support the war. Many Americans, along with myself, wonder why we are continuing this fight. Can you truly answer that question, Mr. President? America is waiting…

A recent polls conducted by CBS News revealed that only 25% of Americans believe that the military can be truly effective in curbing the fight between Iraqis. Half of Americans believe that the war is getting worse and nearly three-fourths reported that they believe the war is going poorly. Two thirds oppose your troop surge, Mr. President, and 45% say that Congress should block funding for more troops in Iraq. As of the beginning of this month 505 billion dollars have been spent on this war and on March 10, 2007 you requested 3.2 billion more dollars to send troops into Iraq. These figures are becoming astronomical!

May I remind you of a speech that you gave May 1, 2003 aboard the USS Abraham Lincoln, you said; “… my fellow Americans: Major combat operations in Iraq have ended. In the battle of Iraq, the United States and our allies have prevailed. And now our coalition is engaged in securing and reconstructing that country.” You gave this speech four years ago and here you are now asking for more troops to be sent into Iraq. This war should have long been over.

Mr. President, the time is now. Stand up for our country and show America that you still believe what is right and what is wrong. Bring the troops home, it’s the right thing to do.


Jeanne Stapleton '07'
Wilkes University
Communications Studies

Friday, March 23, 2007

Americans Can Handle the Truth about Iraq, but Whose Truth?


Can Americans handle the truth about Iraq? Well, according to President Bush during the State of the Union, not really. “We cannot know the full extent of the attacks that we and our allies have prevented.

President Bush left this quote for us to figure out. By not letting us know the full extent to what is really going on in Iraq, it seems he is trying to save us from the fear we may encounter by knowing what is actually happening. President Bush told the nation at one time that the war in Iraq was difficult but winnable. Winnable, I am not so sure, but difficult is clearly the truth. Despite upbeat encouragement by administration officials, the military situation is unimproved; in fact, it is disintegrating day by day. Just a few weeks ago, a U.S. Military base was attacked in broad daylight. Such bold action does not reassure us that Iraq is stabilizing and that U.S. troops are secure. Clearly, the Iraqi Army shows no signs of being able to control the country without American help for years to come. There are not enough American soldiers to carry out the job they have been sent to do, yet the damage to the current force is taking a terrible toll on the ability of the United States to defend its security on other fronts around the world.


The Bush Administration has been saying that Iraq would be worth American sacrifices, but Americans are really wondering whether our sacrifices could actually produce a democratic Iraq. This War, and make no mistake about the fact that this is a war, has been going on now years, and yes, there has been some progress, but not enough to prove this war is the right thing to do. In the recent House Hearing of 2007 Army War Supplemental, there was much talk about how we entered into Iraq unprepared as well as 56 billion dollars short to fund our Army; we should be prepared for this action. Entering into a war unprepared is just not smart. If the U.S. was not prepared, they should have held off.

Many Americans do not want a disaster in Iraq, and the President’s critics can put aside their anger at the administration for its awful planning and its useless conduct of the war in return for a blunt discussion of where to go from here. The President, who is going to be in office for almost another 2 years, cannot continue by tainting Iraq with the memory of 9/11. The nation does not want it and cannot afford it. It seems as though the truth about Iraq is that we are in over our heads. It seems as though President Bush and his administrators are going by the saying “What we don’t know won’t hurt us.” The truth about the truth is it hurts, so we are told something that will comfort us rather then break us down


Many U.S. newspapers as well as many private citizens are pressing the Bush administration for an explanation of how it could have gotten the question of weapons of mass destruction in Iraq so wrong in the march to war. The Dallas Morning News, in Bush's home state, which had supported the war, has now declared;” We feel deceived by the CIA, which overestimated the threat, and by the White House, which probably stretched the bad estimates to build a case for war." If Bush had found other strategic or humanitarian reasons for the war, "he should have argued the case on that basis," the editorial said. Now if the newspapers do not know the truth about Iraq, what makes anyone think your average American does?

An actual truth about Iraq is that this war has no direct link to September 11th. Now, Americans know that truth. However, how should Americans react when President Bush continues to link the two? I think the President owes this nation an apology, for misleading us about going to war and acting as if we cannot handle the truth. Terrorists did not come and steal our newly regained sense of being Americans. Neither did the Democrats, nor did the media, nor did the people. The President and those around him did that. Therefore, too, have they succeeded, and are still succeeding as long as this government uses 9/11 as a lock to turn Americans against Americans.


Katie Cappelloni

Wilkes Communications Studies Major


Thursday, March 22, 2007

When Are the Troops Coming Home?

President Bush has once again started searching for support for the war in Iraq. But where exactly does he expect to find this support? Not from the Democrats. And much of the American population probably won’t support him either. Let’s take a look at some of the recent situations as to why people may be questioning Bush’s plans:
  • On January 10th, 2007, President Bush revealed his “New Way Forward” and said that 20,000 American troops were being sent to Iraq.
  • When the 2008 budget proposal was released on February 5th, 2007, Bush asked for $145 billion to be set aside for use in the war.
  • As of March 1st, 2007, $505 billion has been spent on the war in Iraq since it’s beginning.
  • On Saturday, March 10th, 2007, President Bush requested $3.2 billion to pay for 8,200 additional troops to go to Iraq. More troops = more money and most likely, more causalities.
  • As of Sunday, March 18th, 2007, 3220 American troops have been killed, and over 20,000 wounded.

This war started in 2003. We’re going on year four – during which time I, have graduated high school and in three months, will be graduating college. Whether it was someone from school who has risked his or her life to fight for our country, or a friend who’s had their friend overseas, almost everyone (including myself) has known someone involved in the war. Being a sociology major, I can’t help but look at how this affects the general public. The war in Iraq takes its toll on various members of society, from parents, to spouses, to children. Many support the troops, but few support the reasons they are there.

Because the troops have not yet been pulled out, the war in Iraq has a good chance of becoming a major responsibility of the next President of the United States. And what a burden to take on. Many candidates have been making sure that the voting population is aware of where they stand in regards to the war and what they plan to do to change our current situation. But if Bush is unable to finish what he has started overseas, we also need to ask how a new President, whether Democrat or Republican, will handle the situation once they come into power. Instead of focusing on how the candidates felt about the initial troop surge back in 2003, America needs to start hearing workable plans from each candidate to pull the troops out of Iraq.

Pulling the troops out of Iraq needs to be a main focus of our candidates because no one can deny that it is a very important issue. I believe I speak for many when I say that we want the US troops to come home safely, but it’s hard to be optimistic when the end of the war keeps getting pushed further and further out of sight. Please Mr. President, start giving us some hope to grasp onto instead of leaving us wondering when our troops are going to come home and our deficit is going to stop growing.

Kate Broda '07
Wilkes University
Sociology & Communication Studies Major